Trecaso's Mary Coyle Fine Italian Cuisine & Ice Cream Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Trecaso's Mary Coyle Fine Italian Cuisine & Ice Cream, a culinary gem nestled in Akron, Ohio. With its charming decor and a nod to nostalgia, this restaurant offers a delightful mix of Italian classics and irresistible ice cream creations.
The menu is a vibrant blend of flavors. Start with a classic Onion Pizza or indulge in the Tuna Fish Pizza. Those preferring pasta can savor the artfully prepared Shrimp Ravioli or Manicotti, both showcasing rich, authentic Italian flavors. Sandwich lovers can delight in the hearty Meatball Sandwich or the fresh Tuna Salad Sandwich.
Of course, the true star might just be the ice cream. Locals rave about the peanut butter fudge and the killer Black Raspberry Shake. Trecaso's is known for great service, making it ideal for a casual meal or a sweet treat. Don't miss the chance to experience this charming establishment—a delightful escape for both foodies and ice cream aficionados!
Pizza
Plain Pizza
Tomato and cheese.
Italian Sausage Pizza
Homemade Sausage
Green Peppers Pizza
Fresh Cut Green Peppers
Banana Peppers Pizza
Hot Banana Peppers
Onion Pizza
Fresh Diced Onions
Mushroom Pizza
Fresh Mushrooms
Black Olive Pizza
Anchovy Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Tuna Fish Pizza
Fresh Tomatoes Pizza
2 Items Pizza
3 Items Pizza
4 Items Pizza
Garlic Pizza
No tomato sauce.
Create Your Own Pizza
Pick your toppings
Chicken Parmigiano
Baked breast of chicken topped with Provolone. Served on a bed of spaghetti.
Spaghetti
Imported Noodles made to order. Served with our Award Winning sauce.
Veal Cannelloni
Crepes stuffed with a blend of veal and fresh ricotta.
Stuffed Eggplant
Eggplant stuffed with Ricotta, baked & served in a sizzling casserole.
Ravioli
Stuffed with Ricotta cheese.
Lasagna
Fresh ricotta, imported Romano topped with Provolone.
Italian Sausage Parmigiano
Our own homemade sausage topped with Provolone. Served on a bed of spaghetti.
Tortellini
Spinach egg noodle stuffed with Ricotta cheese.
Spaghetti with Clam Sauce
Clams and garlic sauteed in butter & olive oil. With our Award Winning red or white sauce.
Manicotti
Crepes stuffed with Ricotta cheese topped with Provolone.
Spaghetti Ad Aglio E Olio
Garlic and Olive Oil.
Spaghetti with Anchovies
Anchovy fillets sauteed in extra virgin olive oil.
Mostacciolli
Rigatoni. Imported Noodles made to order (Like Sewer Pipes).
Baked Fish
White fish, baked & served with our famous spaghetti.
Spaghetti with Calamari Sauce
Homemade sauce with sauteed squid.
Shrimp Ravioli
Stuffed with shrimp & Ricotta cheese.
Gnocchi
Potato pasta (Like Dumplings).
Fettucini Alfredo
Egg noodles covered in our famous rich cheese sauce.
Pasta
Sandwiches
Fish Sandwich
Baked white fish. Served on a toasted bun.
Meatball Sandwich
Fresh made meatballs topped with Provolone.
Sausage Parm Sandwich
A 3-Napkin sandwich - homemade, mildly spiced - fresh tomato sauce topped with melted provolone.
Chicken Parm Sandwich
Fresh tomato sauce topped with melted Provolone. Baked and served on a toasted bun.
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Made fresh daily. Dolphin safe tuna, fresh eggs with a touch of mayo. Add melted Provolone for an additional charge.
Salami Sub
Genoa salami, Provolone, lettuce, tomato and topped with our homemade Italian dressing. Served hot or cold.
Chicago Style Hot Dog
Pure Beef Hot Dog with sliced tomatoes, mustard, onion, relish, pickle, and a sport pepper served on a steamed bun.
Chili Dog
Topped with our homemade chili sauce.
Hot Dog
Pure beef served on a fresh steamed bun.
Chili
A hearty blend of pinto & kidney Beans, with lean beef and tomatoes.
Stuffed Mushrooms
Stuffed with our homemade sausage and walnuts. Topped with Provolone cheese.
Applesauce
Garlic Bread
Baked with Butter and Garlic. Add melted Provolone for an additional charge.
Fresh Tomato Bread
Fresh tomatoes baked with garlic and melted Provolone cheese.
Meatballs in Tomato Sauce
2 fresh homemade meatballs served with our Award Winning Sauce.
Bread and Butter
Appetizers
Salads
Antipasto Salad
A hearty salad with mixed greens, genoa salami, aged Provolone, pepperoncini, fresh tomatoes, cabbage & carrots. Served with fresh bread & butter.
Jumbo Salad
A meal in itself.
Garden Salad
Side Salad
Chicken Parm
Baked breast of chicken topped with melted provolone.
2 Meatballs
Served with our Award Winning sauce.
Italian Dressing 12 oz Bottle
12oz Bottle Trecaso's Homemade Italian Dressing ready for pickup
Italian Sausage Parm
Homemade, Baked and topped with Melted Provolone
Add Ons
Ice Cream
2 Scoop Dish
Two scoops of your favorite ice cream or sherbet
16 oz Pint Container of Ice Cream
16 oz Pint Container of Mary Coyle Homemade Ice Cream Ready for Pick Up
32 oz Quart Container of Ice Cream
32 oz Quart Container of Mary Coyle Homemade Ice Cream Ready for Pick Up
The Original
Vanilla, strawberry and chocolate, marshmallow and cherry pineapple toppings, crushed nuts and fresh bananas.
The U.S. Mint
3 large scoops of mint chocolate chip, hot fudge topping, crushed nuts and fresh bananas.
The Hot Fudge
3 large scoops of vanilla, hot fudge topping, crushed nuts and fresh bananas.
The Blueberry
3 large scoops of vanilla, marshmallow and blueberry toppings, crushed nuts and fresh bananas.
The Chocolate
3 large scoops of chocolate, marshmallow and chocolate toppings, crushed nuts and fresh bananas.
The Strawberry
3 large scoops of vanilla, marshmallow topping, gobs of strawberries, crushed nuts and fresh bananas.
The Butterscotch
3 large scoops of vanilla, marshmallow and butterscotch toppings, crushed nuts and fresh bananas.
The Peanut Butter
3 large scoops of vanilla, marshmallow and peanut butter toppings, crushed nuts and fresh bananas.
Banana Bowls
Showboats
Tin Roof
Vanilla, chocolate topping and Spanish peanuts.
Buckeye
Peanut butter fudge, hot fudge topping and crushed nuts.
Merry Mint
Peppermint chip and hot fudge topping.
Mint Fudge
Green mint, hot fudge topping and crushed nuts.
Pina Colada
Coconut and pineapple topping.
English Nut
Vanilla and maple walnut topping.
Copper Roof
Vanilla, butterscotch topping and spanish peanuts.
Hot Tin Roof
Vanilla, hot fudge topping and Spanish peanuts.
Razz-Ma-Tazz
Vanilla, red raspberry, marshmallow toppings and crushed nuts.
Mocha Magic
Old colonial coffee, marshmallow and maple walnut toppings.
Banana Royal
Banana, marshmallow topping, crushed nuts and fresh bananas.
Banana Fudge
Banana and hot fudge topping.
Apple Crunch
Vanilla, apple cinnamon and marshmallow toppings and crushed nuts.
Perfect Peach
Vanilla, fresh peach and marshmallow toppings and crushed nuts.
Blueberry Hill
Vanilla, marshmallow and blueberry toppings.
Cherry Cordial
Chocolate chip, chocolate and burgundy cherry toppings.
Burgundy Snow
Burgundy cherry, marshmallow and burgundy cherry toppings and flaked coconut.
Coconut Fudge
Vanilla, hot fudge topping, coconut and fresh bananas.
Chocolate Dream
Chocolate butter fudge, marshmallow topping, crushed nuts and fresh bananas.
Chocolate Mellow
Vanilla and chocolate, marshmallow and chocolate toppings.
Jacks Maple Marvel
Maple walnut, hot fudge topping, Spanish peanuts and fresh bananas.
Almond Toffee Treat
Butter toffee almond, marshmallow and butterscotch toppings.
Strawberry Supreme
Strawberry, marshmallow topping and fresh bananas.
Banana Butterscotch
Vanilla, marshmallow and butterscotch toppings, crushed nuts and fresh bananas.
Peanut Butter & Jelly
Vanilla, peanut butter and black raspberry toppings.
Peanut Butter Sundae
Cherry Sundae
Pineapple Sundae
Hot Fudge Sundae
Blueberry Sundae
Chocolate Sundae
Fresh Peach Sundae
Burgundy Cherry Sundae
Black Raspberry Sundae
Strawberry Sundae
Butterscotch Sundae
Marshmallow Sundae
Red Raspberry Sundae
Apple Cinnamon Sundae
Cherry Pineapple Sundae
Chocolate Marshmallow Sundae
Butterscotch Marshmallow Sundae
Hot Fudge Coconut Delight Sundae
Vanilla - Hot Fudge Topping Flaked Cocoanut
Sundaes
Milk Shakes
Regular Milk Shake
Specialty Shakes
Old Fashioned Soda
Frothy Soda with Two Large Scoops of Vanilla Ice Cream
Old Fashioned Sodas
Boston Cooler
Boston Cooler
Ice cream, soda water with flavor syrup. A light milkshake.
Sherbet Freeze
Sherbet and soda water. A refreshing mix!