Welcome to Trecaso's Mary Coyle Fine Italian Cuisine & Ice Cream
Trecaso's Mary Coyle Fine Italian Cuisine & Ice Cream is a cherished gem nestled in Akron, OH, blending rich Italian culinary tradition with delightful, nostalgic ice cream creations. Founded by passionate foodies, this establishment exudes warmth and community spirit, with a menu featuring artisan pizzas, homemade pastas, and freshly crafted sandwiches. Each dish reflects dedication to quality, prepared with locally sourced ingredients and recipes passed down through generations. The ice cream, hailed as some of the best in Ohio, elevates the dining experience with unique flavors and a whimsical atmosphere. Trecaso's is truly a slice of history that promises satisfaction and a sweet escape for all.
-
780 W Market St, Akron, OH 44303 Hotline: (330) 253-1511
Trecaso's Mary Coyle Fine Italian Cuisine & Ice Cream is a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Akron, Ohio, at 780 W Market St. This restaurant is a delightful fusion of Italian culinary expertise and rich, nostalgic ice cream offerings, serving a menu that truly embodies the essence of fine dining coupled with the warmth of a classic ice cream parlor.
Upon entering, guests are greeted by a charming atmosphere, filled with memorabilia that pays homage to the past. It’s a throwback to the golden era of diners, where laughter and good food create an inviting ambiance. Notably, the staff, including the warm and welcoming Michael, have been staples in the community, ensuring that each visitor feels like family.
- Pizza: The pizza menu is a tantalizing journey. From the classic Pepperoni Pizza to the unique Garlic Pizza—a delightful choice without tomato sauce—there's something to please every palate. Prices start at just $10.50.
- Pasta: Taste the tradition with dishes like the Spaghetti with Calamari Sauce or Lasagna made from fresh ricotta and imported Romano, each priced under $12.00, highlighting their commitment to quality ingredients and homemade styles.
- Sandwiches: Sandwich lovers rejoice with options like the Sausage Parm Sandwich and the Tuna Salad Sandwich, made fresh daily. Each sandwich is not just a meal but an experience, with prices around $7.75 - $7.95.
However, the real magic happens after the main course, where you can indulge in their exquisite ice cream. As praised by visitors, Trecaso’s ice cream isn’t just dessert; it’s an adventure. Flavors range from classic Butter Pecan, touted as the best ever by guests, to exciting options like Peanut Butter Fudge. Customers recommend trying a pint of every flavor—an invitation to indulge in pure joy!
In a recent review, Andrew Rulnick expressed his admiration, calling it a “slice of history and the best ice cream in Ohio.” The feedback is echoed by others who highlight not only the superb quality of the ice cream but the delicious nostalgia wrapped in every scoop.
Overall, Trecaso's Mary Coyle Fine Italian Cuisine & Ice Cream is more than just a dining spot; it’s a celebration of tradition, hospitality, and culinary delight. Whether you are in the mood for authentic Italian dishes or a sweet treat to satiate your cravings, this restaurant promises an unforgettable experience that resonates with all who visit.
Slice of history and best ice cream in Ohio. Its a little bit of the sweets to keep the blood flowing seriously you will not be disappointed in the quality of the ice cream. Try a pint of every flavor dont stop until you have had them ...
Such a wonderful place to get ice cream. The inside is beautiful. Throw back to the old days. The employees are really nice and patient.
The shop itself is adorable and full of memorabilia. The gentleman at the counter was warm and welcoming. My first experience here at the recommendation of an APD friend, and I would highly recommend to anyone. Check out the menu on the door and online before you go! Very efficient process ...
Stopped in for ice cream and what a cute place .. nostalgic. I loved the sense of humor from the gentleman who helped us. He was quick and efficient as well. As for the ice cream.. delish!! Got the peanut butter fudge!!
When passing thru Highland Square in Akron, stop in for a sweet surprise. The menu caters to the foodie in you..
If youre looking for delicious ice cream and a relaxed atmosphere, this is it. Michael who has been a staple in the community for over 40 years was wonderful and the service was great. My black raspberry shake was delicious and just what I ...
Had a good experience. Checked out the menu outside, ordered inside, and waited outside for our food. We split a cheese pizza, which was really good! Then had the peanut butter banana bowl it was incredible! First off, it was massive. I ...
Without a doubt this was the best icecream I have had ever! We have been on a hunt for the BEST Butter Pecan in the areas around Alliance, Ohio where I reside. As of this evening, I may have found it! The pecans were the best I have ever ...